The film takes place 40 years after the original murders in Amityville, New York. The movie opens in Amityville then after the credits picks up in small town Nebraska where a cursed antique toy monkey from the opening scene possesses a father when it is given to him as a birthday gift, one similar to what he had as a child.

• The Amityville Legacy
• Mark Popejoy
• Jade Michael LaFont
• Julia Farrell
• Dustin Ferguson
• Mike Johnson